When email open rates drop noticeably, most people start by changing the send time. But the first things to check are the two things recipients see first in their inbox: the sender name and the subject line. The five tweaks below can be tested today without touching your sending infrastructure.
1. Put a person in the sender name
A sender that shows only a company name is easily sorted as promotion. A name like “Story Light’s Sarah Kim” tends to get opened more often than just “Story Light,” even with the same content. Using an address where replies actually arrive is another small way to build trust.
2. Put just one promise in the subject line
Cram several things into one subject line and none of them is remembered. State clearly the one thing readers get by opening this email.
When choosing a subject line, a simple method that works is to write three or four candidates and ask teammates which email they’d most want to open. Picking with different sets of eyes builds your instincts much faster than agonizing alone over the perfect sentence.
- Add a number or a specific object (“3 Steps to Designing Lead Scoring”)
- Write it so it flows into the preview text
- Use no more than one exclamation point or emoji at a time
A good subject line doesn’t make people want to open the email; it makes sure they aren’t disappointed when they do.
The Story Light editorial team
3. Clean up who you send to first
A large number of subscribers who haven’t opened anything in a long time pulls down your overall open rate and can lead mailbox providers to treat your email as low priority. Move subscribers with no activity in the last few months to a separate list and manage them on their own.
Run enough experiments and you’ll find that a surprising number of people never open your emails but stay subscribed. They often value the email itself and simply don’t like the subject lines. Sometimes changing the subject line alone brings them back.
4. Learn send times from your own customers
A general rule like “Tuesday at 10 a.m. is best” is less accurate than the times your own subscribers actually open email. Look at the distribution of open times over the past few months and test the top two time slots in alternation.
5. Change one thing at a time and keep a record
If you change the subject, sender, and time all at once, you can’t tell what worked. Change one thing at a time and log the results in a table, and in three months you’ll have a rulebook unique to your team.
Don’t judge results by open rate alone
Open rate is only the share of people who opened; it doesn’t tell you whether the email helped. Because of the way mail apps preload images, it can read higher or lower than reality, so it’s best not to swing with every number.
That’s why we recommend reading open rate alongside click rate, reply count, and unsubscribe rate. For example, if opens went up but clicks stayed flat, the subject line may be promising more than the content delivers; if unsubscribes rose, it may be a signal to send less often.
On mobile mail apps, subject lines are often cut short. Put the most important words up front and write the preview text to complement the subject line. After writing a subject line, check how it looks on your own phone.
Also, if you keep repeating the same subject line format, recipients get used to it and response can slowly fade. Occasionally switch formats, such as a question, a number, or a story, and see which works for your subscribers.
What to decide before you start testing
Before testing a tweak, write down what you’ll count as success. Without criteria, it’s easy to cherry-pick the numbers that look good.
- Match the comparison period and the lists you compare
- Write down the success criteria as a numeric range in advance
- If the result is ambiguous, repeat it once more under the same conditions
On small lists, chance differences can look large. Don’t draw conclusions from one or two results; make something a rule only when results point the same way several times.
When logging results, a single line with the date, the element changed, the audience, and the open and click results is enough. A complicated table won’t last, while a simple one keeps getting filled in three months later. We recommend starting with a single spreadsheet.
When a test ends, share the results briefly with your team. Keep the tweaks that didn’t work alongside the ones that did so you don’t repeat the same attempts. A record of failures is sometimes more helpful than a record of successes.
Finally, be careful not to let raising open rate become the goal itself. Sending emails worth reading and acting on comes first; open rate is the metric that follows as a result.
If response doesn’t change after you adjust the sender and subject line, it’s time to look at the content of the email itself. Check whether the reader’s payoff for opening is clear and whether the first two sentences of the body pick up the subject line’s promise right away. The subject line opens the door, and the experience once it’s open determines the open rate of your next email.
Asking subscribers directly what kind of email they want, and how often, is also a good approach. Even a one-line survey or a preference page gives you clues for matching send frequency and topics. People who receive the emails they want will naturally open them.
Summary
Open rate is ultimately a measure of trust. The longest-lasting improvement is getting recipients to remember that “this sender’s emails are worth opening.” This week, start by changing two things: the sender name and the subject line.
Add your first comment to this post